345: MemberVetting: Predictive Indicators & Data Breaches w/ Paul Dank
We welcome back one of our favorite people Paul Dank of Kennis, where he addresses common misconceptions about the simplicity of background checks and delves into the actual difficulties of conducting these investigations in areas with overlapping jurisdictions. This episode covers the financial and legal considerations essential for club managers to know. Listeners will gain practical advice on handling these challenges effectively.
To explore these issues further and receive expert advice, we encourage you to set up a consultation with Paul at Membervetting.com.
Follow us on the socials
Private Club Radio Instagram
Private Club Radio Linkedin
Denny Corby Instagram
Denny Corby Linkedin
0:00 Steve actually had the Antiguan Coast Guard called out and they stopped the ship and they kicked he and the wife off the ship and they're banned from the cruise line forever. And none of that was posted directly by him. I'm pretty sure he doesn't want his employer to see that Works for big companies, but it's there, and so where you let me look dictates how much I'm going to find, and then from there it's not easy. It's not as easy as getting the tech savvy kid that works in the office of the club to look on Facebook. Hey, everyone. Welcome back to Private Club Radio, your industry source for news trends, updates and conversations all in the world of private clubs and high-end hospitality.
0:41 And when we say private clubs, we mean country clubs, city clubs, golf clubs, yacht clubs, athletic clubs, military clubs, all the clubs. I'm your host, denny Corby. Thanks for being here. And back on again. Today we have our friend Paul Denk from over at Kenneth's Member Vetting and we zero in on the pivotal roles that predictive behaviors in member vetting play in the member application process. Paul and I also touch on the complexities of the member removal process, legal nuances for conducting background checks and some of the potential risks clubs face when they rely on informal sources for their vetting processes.
1:22 And we're going to learn on the different levels and packages a little bit that Kennis offers when it comes to your member vetting. If you don't know who Kennis is, they are a specialized intelligence gathering division of ASG Investigations serving private clubs in their member applicant vetting processes. So if you're interested in discovering how fact-based member vetting could protect your club's reputation and integrity, head on over to membervettingcom and set up a consult with our friend Paul Denk. And now onto the show. There's 70 models to a lot of these clubs. Some are exclusive by virtue of being that top 5% of the clubs in terms of price point.
2:03 You know, come on, I mean the best GMs that I work with say that we help with their culture. And oh damn okay. So I was going to say because that leads right into predictive information, but I wanted to talk about Diddy. Yeah, we'll come back to it. No, I already hit recording. I was like, oh, this is going to be a perfect segue, but no, we were chatting and I brought up Diddy and just because it's like a relevant topic now, and what?
2:43 Because you know, you know I do magic and stuff. So what you're saying about predicting the future, it's not predicting the future, it was predictive information. Yeah, well, what we do is provide information and there's two ways that we provide it Reactively, when something bad has happened and somebody says can you help us get our arms around the extent of this and who's at fault and you know what led to it. Right, that's reactive In terms of the club space. It's proactive and the whole thing is based on the same tenants that you have a college application for, the same tenants that you would have a. You know that you would have pre-employment screening for. It's that past actions and facts are indicative of future behavior. You know, and I've said, I think on your show that I'm an optimist.
3:27 I'm not really an optimist at all, but I say I'm an optimist and I believe that people can always turn a new leaf, except that they don't, you know. And so we do have those rare moments where somebody actually figures it out and changes. Is that? Guessing when that's going to happen is probably not in anybody's best interest, whether it's membership in a club or for a job or any other reason that you would met someone and associations are really good at this. They've got standards for a reason. If somebody isn't meeting the standards, now's the time, don't let them in when it comes to the club world, you know, removing somebody is a nightmare. When it comes to the club world, you know, removing somebody is a nightmare. There's usually very you know very detailed process you have to go through, which involves disciplining the person in second try and third try.
4:12 Each club is different, but that process is a mess. And so when you have somebody who shouldn't have gotten in in the first place, wow, what a waste of energy and resources, what a hit to the reputation of the club, all unnecessary. If you actually looked at facts and said we can't just rely on others vouching for people. And there's a really um, there's a really good book out there that talks about prediction and have you heard of the book um by nam Taleb called Anti-Fragile? The name rings a bell. Okay. Taleb has written a number of books. He's incredibly well-read.
4:53 The business community is all over him. I think anybody that's into behavioral analysis knows him and his work and whether you love him or hate him, anti-fragile really points out it's a very long book. It's a little bit of a technical book. You can't be reading this in bed. Before you fall asleep and soak it in, you need to be focused. But in the end, what it says is humans are really really bad at predicting things and there are a whole bunch of situations that we skew, whether or not they're fragile right, meaning the odds of it failing and not working out the way I predict are very high versus things that are very low. Sports betting is very, very fragile.
5:35 I might think I know all about who's going to win the college football playoff next year, but I don't and I'm biased toward teams and people and I have a lack of information. But I tell myself no way my team's going to win. So that's a little bit of an example. But this is no different for wealthy people that are on a member committee, on a board at a club, deciding someone's state whether it's a membership director, whether it's a GM we're really bad at predicting things, and when we have less information meaning it's all information controlled by the applicant, maybe a little bit of contribution from other members in the club they don't have all the information.
6:17 And now we're doing this feel-good prediction that the person's going to work out and we just chose not to have facts. So it's kind of crazy, but the anti-fragile narrative plays out over and over again in this case. That's why, if you look at something and I go back to this because I think it works really well what it takes to get accepted into a public university, think about the process and all the documentation and all the review that they do and all the money they spend looking over those applications, because they actually know what's going to be successful at a university. They have really good predictive measures of whether you're going to make it or not. And, yeah, there's always going to be the person that flakes out and you wouldn't expect it to.
6:59 You know the kid who has really good grades and really good behavior and then gets to the open light and space of being in a public university, right, and ends up drinking themselves out in the first term. It happens, but more than likely if you have someone that hasn't been a good student that hasn't behaved a certain way, they're going to wash out in a much greater proportion than the good students. So universities really have this down. Clubs just haven't embraced the fact. They've said we're kind of void of information and that information goes a long way. So the predictive value is I want to believe that you're saying you're going to be an amazing member, but I'd also like to see some actual reasons that I should believe that you're a physician to do that and when there are things that we find in that background information and in the OSIP research that show us that they actually behave differently, you know that that's the predictive value right there.
7:58 This isn't every like. How often do you find weird stuff? I shouldn't say weird stuff Like how often. I think you've told me that before. Most people are like. Most things you find are. You know it's all good, everything matches up. It's the few and far between. Yeah. So a little bit of a complicated question because we do different, varying degrees of vetting for clubs. So we have some clubs that are very, very stringent and have us go, you know, soup to nuts, through everything we can. Others are much more restrictive on the data we look at. What I can tell you is that the majority of people that apply for membership clubs there is no derogatory information or contrary information.
8:41 Then we get into varying shades, right. So you put something on your application. It looks to me like it was a misrepresentation. You tried to look like you were you know all that and a bag of chips, and you really weren't even a bag of chips. So, but that's one or two data points. Then you get things like I see behaviors that you probably wouldn't engage in at the club, certainly when you're trying to get in. But if you feel free to do these things in other environments and you've done them in the recent past well gosh, that doesn't bode very well. Maybe I have someone here who's going to be violating the decorum policy before they've even set foot in the door.
9:23 And then you get into finding the behaviors that are not necessarily criminal, but they're indicative of the fact that I don't follow the rules, I don't do what I'm supposed to do, so some of it, I guess you could frame it as criminal, but it's things like how I drive. It's things like citations drive, it's things like citations, problems with insurance claims, right, and you get into aside from overt behaviors where someone is demonstrating insanity so got in big trouble because I jumped off the cruise ship. This is one that we had.
10:03 I jumped off the cruise ship and this is this is one that we had. I jumped off the cruise ship and everybody was super angry and they had the whatever Antiguan Coast Guard out there and they stopped the ship and you know, OK, I mean really, you're grown up, You're 30 and you jumped off because it was hilarious. You know, and this isn't somebody who's like Steve-O from the Jackass series, this is somebody who sells insurance for a living and wants to join a golf club. If you're going to jump off a cruise ship when you get tuned up, what are you going to do with the club when you get tuned up Again? Maybe your club is okay with that, Maybe your club has different standards. But you look for those behavioral things that say I'm not going to to follow rules, I'm going to do what I want and and and it's not up to you and it's not up to you or kennis or anybody to decide who's good and who's bad.
10:55 You're just presenting the information. It's. Ultimately the club can decide like oh, we don't care about that, uh so. So this is just the information that I, I think sometimes clubs look at something like this as it's more in depth and it's like, well, no, it's not, they're not telling anybody what, what to do, it's just hey, we're just finding the juicy information that's just out there, um and so. So here here, here's a how um, you know, with something like that, how difficult is that to find? And like so, like you know I'm trying to think of, like someone applies for membership at my club, how easy is it to find that, or how difficult, or you know. I guess that's another you know question there, but I'll let you answer sure.
11:43 So again, it sort of depends on what the club is engaging me, how deep they're engaging us to look. I've talked previously about the fact that the information is not linear, meaning if you want to find out information about you or me or anyone else, you're going to get some information directly from me, things like my LinkedIn I put that up, I control that information, my Facebook. But really I'll give you the cruise ship jumper example. That was posted by a friend who was on the cruise and it's not tagged as being that member. So if I were on that person's social media I would see the hilarious guy jumping on.
12:25 It doesn't say who it is. So we can identify who he is. The club can identify who he is. It's him. So finding that involved us looking into that sphere, right? So we have to go into buckets where we don't necessarily know there's going to be information and the information is going to be unstructured. When we find it, then we can present it. Now that you know also feeds into the breadcrumbs idea and that's that we find one and then we go to the next one and the next one, and the next one. So opening that up said OK, this person has a group of people and, by the way, we've got coinciding dates. These are the people that were on the ship. These are the people that also are friends with that person. Let's start quickly looking in those buckets. That's when we find the story of Dude and it's by the first name.
13:10 We'll call him Steve. First name we'll call him steve. Steve, uh, actually had the, you know, antiguan coast guard called out and they stopped the ship and they kicked he and the wife off the ship and they're banned from the cruise line forever. Um, you know, and and none of that was posted directly by him I'm pretty sure he doesn't want his employer to see that. Right, right, works for big companies, of course, but it's there, and so where you let me look dictates how much I'm going to find, and then from there it's not easy. It's not as easy as getting the tech savvy kid that works in the in the office of the club to to look on Facebook in the office of the club.
13:57 To look on Facebook Certainly do that, because sometimes that's a layup and you find the easy information, but that's what you're paying for a company like mine to do is to look for any and all facts that aren't easy to find and that takes the right training, the right equipment, access, and the craziest thing is how busy our R&D department is, because things are rolling out at a continuous basis, things like data breach data. Once it becomes public and it's out there, it's full of intimate details about things. But even these breaches that happened four or five years ago. We find all kinds of information from the data breach data which doesn't live anywhere, but if you have it, and you have it on a server and you download it every time data breach information is published.
14:44 Well then, you've got a whole new repository of stuff that people tapping Google are never going to find, but it's public and it's laying around waiting to have. So, in terms of home gamers, thinking about doing what we do and being successful, limited opportunity can you briefly go into like so something like finding mr jumper here, what level package about is? Is that information getting? Is that more of like the? Is that like higher end? Is that more the middle um? no that was something like that was real close to the middle yeah maybe a bit above the middle, I think. In total.
15:24 You know we offer nine packages really, with number nine being the nuclear variant and and number one being a lot of public record data just done correctly. What I mean by that is, if you think about pre-employment screening and the $29.95 super background search that you see advertised all over the web, you want to do a background check in your neighbor, so you go to whatever Zippy search and it's $19.95. Those are data brokers sell information 1995. Those are data brokers sell information. What they also sell you is a disclaimer. So there's several asterisks that say based on where we looked, which was under my iPhone based on where we looked, these are the records that we found.
16:07 And so they limit what they're looking at and they buy data that's already available and it's always incomplete. It's grossly incomplete. They come up with things like a national background check. There is no national background check. Our records are firewalled off. They're very difficult to find If you're using someone with a common name. It's a nightmare. You have to have skills, processes, tools to do that stuff. And so when we offer a low end package, we do the public record thing correctly. We figure out all the places where records could exist and we search all of them. We don't use a data broker who says this is what I've got and no, it's not complete and it'll never be complete.
16:48 They try and be a little more artful with their disclaimers than what I was saying, but that's. The reality is, there isn't a place to go. The CSI shows and the person with the cool haircut on the keyboard who finds everything in five seconds oh, look at this. That's a fantasy, and the record system in this country is becoming more wild than ever before. So you can get the records, but you have to pay to get them. You have to search a certain way, you have to pay, whether or not you get a response or not. These municipalities have figured out this is a money-making adventure now, and so freedom has a price and you have to know who would have jurisdiction.
17:32 We have issues all the time. We have a club that's in Memphis, and it was a struggle with them to say well, you want us to tell you a little bit more, and I said no, because you sit on the border of Mississippi, arkansas and Tennessee. So people have records, and the Arkansas records are not available in Tennessee. No matter how hard I look, I can't find them. They're walled off and if you don't want me to look in those places, don't complain when somebody you talk about. You know you and I have talked about how members will spend all this time doing homework and research on each other and come up with the dirt. Well, they don't have that restriction, so don't restrict me. So you really have to be complete with it.
18:12 But within that package the jumper was probably very near the middle, maybe a little above the middle. We look at the sphere and we do that literally like an onion, one layer at a time. Do you want this additional layer of searching? The bad news with the additional layer is you're spending a little bit of money and a lot of what I'm finding when I go to that next level is stuff I've already found. That's okay. I'm going to find unique stuff, but each time we move a little bit further out, it's probably the law of diminishing returns, so pricing of our packages sort of also decreases, even though we've got a lot of information that we have to find a second time or a third time or a fourth time.
18:57 It's just the nature of the beast In terms of the information we presented and then we presented in a format where things that we think are in the terms responsive, things that we think would actually make someone pause or that they would want to evaluate, we try and put those toward the front of the report. And so if there are things that we find that we know you're going to want to know what is their court record history, for instance right, if they are posting things that are inflammatory directly, obviously those are going to go near the top and we keep going and presenting it in an order Because of the volume of what we find. Most of our report is comprised of links, and those are links to data that we found.
19:41 So it's definitely a data point about Denny Corby, but it really isn't going to make any difference. It's yet another address history in yet another database that's on the web, right. So it's something that we found. It's the fact that you had a MySpace and there's a directory that said that you had a MySpace years ago, and that kind of information usually isn't contributory toward making the decision. But again, we disclose everything that we find and we don't evaluate it, we just present it. We don't evaluate it, we just present it and you know there are things that you can say in Texas that you probably can't socially say in Northern California.
20:27 We're just a diverse country and the behaviors and norms in one place are insults in another. And so I have to leave it up to the clubs to sort of say you know what matters to us and remember, we're not just about yes or no, it's not just red or green. Sometimes there's a conversation to be had, so we'll provide data and someone will say well, this is an unfortunate thing, but it was five years ago. It's not the best, but I'm going to bring it up to the member and I'm going to remind them that at the club, something like that would really be frowned upon. And to make sure that you're clear that you're joining a club where the behaviors are different than those and you set the tone, how about you have that conversation and then they defend themselves and say no, I'm going to act however I want.
21:10 Oh, cool, Now I just need to give out your unfit for membership, you know. And it gives the clubs opportunities to work with that data in different ways to help them with the decision making process. It's not always a layup, the guy that jumps off the ship I'm betting there's some clubs that would say he jumps off the cabana roof into the pool a couple of times. You know, with the Jagermeister it's OK and other clubs it would be. This is not the right time. I think that that's a big part of it. What's going on in your life and is this the right time? I had a club who came back and called me and said you found that the police were at their house four times in the last year. I did yes, that's correct, that's the data.
21:55 Four times the police were called to the house. I don't have more than that. That department doesn't tell me the nature of the runs. But what's going on in the house? The police are coming four times. How often have the police been to your house, danny? Probably a lot in your case. Regular folk usually don't need the police a lot and four doesn't four times stand out. So what's going on? So when you add four times to some other behaviors that say maybe I'm not a perfect fit, it makes it a lot easier. But that's I think that's the whole point of being exclusive, right, that's the whole point of you. Have to exclude sometimes and you have to set a baseline, and I think there's probably even situations where now is not the right time for you to join our club.
22:39 We're being a little bit choosy and you have more defects than most of our normal members. Why am I rolling the dice on you right now? Maybe we'll see in a couple of years if it changes. That's a decision that they're going to have to make, but I think I think you have people think about it this way. Would you invest money with someone that was showing signs that they don't follow the rules? And also, you found out I told you from an investment due diligence standpoint they were. They had the police in their house four times. No, they don't have a criminal record for the shooting. They wouldn't have taken away a handcuff. Would that make you feel super good about handing them $3 million to start a new venture?
23:21 Probably not. At a minimum, there'd be a conversation, right, and you'd hope that there'd be a really quick answer. And you know what. You can always call me back and say this is the answer they gave me. Can you help me verify that? That's always a possibility. Clubs can always call and say here's the additional information we obtained about that. Can you provide the insight? Sometimes I can't. Sometimes there isn't more to get. But a lot of times there is once I know something else. I was saying this earlier. I feel like now is the time for clubs to try so many new things and like push the barrier a little bit, or even like now is the time to, if they might want to do a little bit more of like investigative, backgroundy, fact checking on their members.
24:07 Like now is the time there's. There's hasn't been a better. You know, demand is so much much higher than supply for clubs and membership and the waitlist. Like now is the time more than ever, to be pickier with your members, because you can, because if you don't like someone, it's not like you don't have a have a, have a waitlist Now. You have so many people waiting to come in, just wait, so why not? This is the time now to do it. Well, listen, I agree with you and the industry is the time now to do it. Well, listen, I agree with you and the industry is doing great and it's fantastic. And the number of clubs we contact with waitlist is almost 100 percent. I'm sure the number of clubs that contact us, it's almost 100 percent.
24:48 And some have waitlist in absolutely every category. Some have maybe one or two categories that are open, of maybe one or two categories that are open. But remember, despite it being a good time to be choosy, a big part of using Kennis is because you don't want to put yourself in a position where, as a club, you just decided not to look for the bad information and then the bad event happens and board members love to say well, we've never had a mass shooting at our club, so we're going to assume that that's just not the kind of thing that happens here. At whatever Hearst you know we're, we don't do things. It would be in poor taste to have a mass shooting and none of our members do that. Ok, what's that always just about a mass shooting? I can't tell you how many lawsuits are filed against clubs because of behavior of a member.
25:31 And look at anybody that you want to. Look at a celebrity that has broken. Look at a media, look at somebody who's been involved in a mass shooting. What's the first thing the media does? They do exactly what we do. They do their version of it. But they dig into the past and they try and say look at all the predicted things that were leading up to this. Every time our government, the people that are trying to protect us, had an incident, and the incident goes through, somebody in the media will say look at all the predicted things. And the government failed to catch this person. They knew this person was a problem, right? This person was going to blow up a building or this person was going to shoot somebody and you could see that it was coming.
26:12 That's exactly what we're talking about going to shoot somebody and you could see that it was coming. That's exactly what we're talking about. So, over and above refining and honing the culture of your club by letting in people that truly are going to fit in the club, forget about that. It's the reasonableness of saying we just choose not to look, we're just going to go with recommendations, because we always have. Clearly, the world has changed. If you look around, there is no organized, structured anything from employment to volunteering that doesn't have some level of fact-based vetting going on. Clubs are just fine and they're uniquely positioned for a fraction of the initiation fee to meet that and keep the wolves at bay.
26:57 A lot of the time you're going to find predictive stuff and those are the people that end up breaking. And I know you and I have talked about this. Your strata in society has nothing to do with your odds of having a mental health condition, and in no way am I picking on people that have a mental health condition. But when people that have a mental health condition and in no way am I picking on people that have a mental health condition but when people don't have a mental health condition for somebody, somebody's still going to fail. If there were predictive values and the cause really doesn't matter, does it? If it was somewhat predictable to say this person really isn't suited for membership, so at a minimum you've got to do it in hopes of getting that. Let's say it's one in 10, let's say it's one in 15. Members that are hard enough, we send something back and it's a hard enough not fit for membership.
27:40 That alone is the value. And if it's bad enough, if somebody actually gets hurt at the hands of a member. What is the price associated with that? That would be 50 years of canistese, 100 years of canistese, versus one situation where a staff member got hurt, a guest got hurt, another member got hurt. You know, come on, it's a no-brainer. But the rest of society has looked at this and said we're 100% adapting it because it works. The predicted value holds true. And what I said about anti-fragile it's true. We are terrible at predicting, we're just awful at it, and everybody likes to say they're a good judge of character.
28:21 There is no such thing. There is no such thing. That's just arrogance and listen. I used to do it too, until I started seeing. You know, my judgment, combined with facts, was a lot better than my judgment. And I'm really smart. Just ask me. How smart are you, Paul? I'm uber smart. It's kind of scary. Plus, the coolest reason to work with Canis is to tell people we have a guy in Detroit that takes care of these things. You don't want to say that you need to call the guy from detroit. That's where my yankees at so there's a phrase that I heard and then you have your way of saying it and it's actually come up more.
29:10 It's more common than I thought would be and it's my members are better investigators. Yes, so we like to talk about books, you and I, malcolm Galwell. Yep 10,000 Hours, right, you and I yeah, welcome goldwell. Yep. 10 000 hours, right. So there, there are people who will invest 10 000 hours in digging and snooping. It's a variant of what we do. You got to put the time in. It's not the same, because you're usually stuck with google to do your digging, but you can do the same thing. Somebody can spend endless amounts of time saying who is Denny, who's Denny Spear?
29:50 Now, let me start looking into those people. Let me connect the dots manually on my own, and a lot of times they can find it to social media, but sometimes they'll get the public records and things like that. Your members also have the benefit of gossip. So in a lot of tight communities and this doesn't apply to all clubs, because you can't you can't say that you're in metropolitan um, los angeles or atlanta, and it's a. You know, it's a tight-knit community. It's not a tight-knit community there's people moving in and out all the time. There's people from all over the the world is becoming much more transient people moving for work opportunities, marriage, whatever.
30:31 But when you do get a tight-knit community with a club, in it, there's a lot of information and there is a lot of gossip. This is interesting to me because you will have clubs who will take action on someone's application based on gossip said by other members. In a way, it kind of works, but it's also kind of broken. It works because if the members that are telling you this stuff are concerned about it and there aren't any good members, well then that's a pretty good indicator. The person's probably not going to work out right, but you're willing to toss their application over those conversations which could be contrived and maybe aren't based on a lot of facts or valid information, but clubs will act on that.
31:19 So the good news is it gives you an opportunity to keep people out that aren't going to be a good fit or have potentially exposure and liability. So you're doing the ultimate correct thing, you think, but you're doing it without fact. You're doing it based on somebody's subjective interpretation of things. So unless they can say this, you know I had a club who called me and said there's someone who said that this person's teen son was sexually aggressive with another community member's daughter and this is something that they're thinking about calling the police, and I said I don't know, I can't find a fact. So if that's true, that's terrible, and if it's true, it's not in a searchable fashion, and it sounds like something that somebody said.
32:10 So is it true? And then this is all third party, right? This is a third party for somebody else who knows the mom of the girl and and I said, no, we'll look, we'll look, but there's nothing floating around in public domain that points to that one official that says it actually happened and somebody was convicted. So long answer so no, no, no, because it's, it's. It was just fascinating that when you know, it just came up in conversation. Um, because for me, you know, I, when chatting with people, things come up, and you know, so it was. It was talking about the vetting, because I was asking they had a big wait list.
32:50 All this and multiple times. So do you guys have like a vetting process or anything? And our members are pretty good at that. All right, I'll give you an interesting story. I actually told this a couple times before to prospective clubs, the Detroit Lions, who are doing much, much better, who are doing much, much better. But in the past the Detroit Lions had a coach who came in and this is an employment situation, so it's governed by different rules than the private club standard. But they had a coach well-known. Kate McPatricia came over from the Patriots, took over as head coach.
33:30 He was here, I think, for a year and a half when a reporter from the Detroit Free Press called the GM of the Lions and just said did you know, matt Patricia was arrested for sexual assault down in Texas when he was in college and it was just stymied right. And so, instead of saying what he should have, which is I'm aware of it number one, number two, he was not convicted. And number three, from an employment perspective, I can't even consider that he was not convicted of anything, and it happened a long, long time ago and I'm aware of it. The problem was the Lions were not aware of it, so they brought him over. It sounds like they didn't vet him at all because he was already in the NFL.
34:15 He was already known, right. Everybody recognized his face. Everybody knew who he was, so they brought him in without vetting him. And here's the difference. It's the same thing that you're talking about. Where you have these members that will invest all kinds of energy digging up dirt, who's the last to know? In this case, the alliance management, but the club's management. Hennis, affords clubs and companies like mine. Afford a club an opportunity to avoid that from happening. Isn't it much better to say hey? A member approached me and I was able to tell them we're aware of that and that was not a factor that was critical in the decision making. So, yes, we're aware of it and yes, they're a member, or, better yet, you take care of it and you never have to be on the flip side of that coin, which is, oh, we didn't know, and that's really bad because we never would have let them in it.
35:06 Just you know. It doesn't make sense to go without saying we did the due diligence, because whatever my team is going to do, we're going to run laps around that number, no matter how much time they put into it. If you're giving us a package that allows us to do the complete search, there's no way around it. Do you ever find things that make the person better like people who like underplay their stuff 100, so so it's like people like, oh, this isn't this, but you find out. It's like oh, they donated a billion dollars to this. Oh, they did that. Like, oh, I didn't realize they're responsible for this. Do you ever get clubs that are surprised by how much better members are or people are that are applying?
35:47 Absolutely so two things we usually don't get feedback on members, good or bad. Sometimes I'll ask a question if it's borderline bad. Or they might say, hey, is there anything else with this account? Or there was a person on Twitter who was attacking a prospective member a lot and they said can you give us any context on that person? We'll give you a couple bucks to figure out. Tell me that person. And it turns out that's what that person does is just attacks people. And we did find a nexus in their backgrounds. I think they worked together at one point. So I don't know, I don't think it was very credible, Not for me to decide, but the idea is you know what?
36:28 I'm sorry, Danny, I'm losing my train of thought here. Finding good people, and then, oh, and then you don't really. And then it was one of those, as I was saying, the question I probably I figured no, but clubs aren't going to come back Like yo. This person is so much better than we thought. Yeah, you're absolutely right. It does happen where it's the exact opposite and they say we really didn't realize. You know how good of a patron of the community this person is. They're very humble and quiet and it turns out they do an awful lot and we've got a real treasure. Yes, absolutely. I don't know Cause we were. We were just talking about like bad stuff. I was like I wonder if clubs if you just find all this amazing information and club was like wow, he's too good for here Our membership our membership to eat them.
37:13 Eat them alive, Sir, you don't want to be here. I think the focus is clearly on making sure that they're they're bad, bad things, as opposed to confirming all the good things or finding even more good things. But yeah, listen, there's. There's far more good people that are true, with their intention, who join clubs and their own. What should clubs do? So, going back, you know the, the, the membership is. You know the members are chatting in the hallway and it gets back to the. You know the people in charge of the of the. You know the people in charge of the of the. You know members, membership committees or whoever's. You know, uh, the, the the last say what should?
37:54 What happens when you hear a rumor? well, you're asking the wrong guy. Um, here's what I know. Clubs have been dealing with this for the last 150 plus years and I think, based on conversations with a number of people, that the informal, subjective decisions get made pretty easily, that when there's a blackmail, a warning situation, whatever you want to call it, clubs are happy to say no if they have some information and it's information that didn't come from a guy like me that's where we fit in is trying to fill the void of facts. And it's pretty rare that we get called to say can you confirm anything, like we did the situation with the two teenagers.
38:41 It's pretty rare that we get that call, but we do get that call where they'll say this is something we were told and we'd like to look a little bit further. Other times they'll say, hey, without some proof of it, we don't have a choice but to agree. I think that just gets down to the culture of your club and how selected they are. Gotcha, I think it happens all the time. The other thing that clubs seem to do is they will call a prior club that you are as an applicant or a member of, and they will have informal discussions and if that discussion is, hey, you don't want to call on your club, he's a problem you will blackball that person based off of that conversation.
39:22 And I would say that that's actually actionable. When there's somebody I was a member of the club and someone was speaking about me and characterizing me directly and they're speaking on my behalf about that relationship and I'm getting blackballed and you're not telling me why. I think that there's a great deal of exposure. There's a way for clubs to do that correctly. But having a quick, what can you tell me about that? Oh, okay, good, yeah, I'm going to go in there. I don't think that's a very good idea. Now there are club members, gms, that know each other very well and I think that that has happened. But I think it's an area of risk and if people know that you made that phone call and things get hot enough, I could see that coming up.
40:10 I could see people focusing on that. So I would say that that is definitely not a must practice. What about when members do it? What about when members see, oh, they're a member of that club. Oh, Phyllis is a member of that club. Let me talk to Phyllis. What about when it's that chain of command? I think, especially if it's negative, they'll come back and report oh, this person has, you know, had their golfing privileges taken away and membership suspended multiple times. Yeah, it's no different than saying the person is bad in the community for the following reasons or you know they're up to shady things, or you know the members are going to report those things. And I think clubs, like I said, have been dealing with it for a very long time.
40:51 So they already have a process to dealing with that. And again, some of the time we're asked who can come in and find anything to substantiate this claim, because it's not great. But a lot of times yeah, I think they've already been dealing with it and that happens in a lot of times. Yeah, I think they've already been dealing with that and that happens in a lot of different circumstances. I mean, look at Greek life on campus. People will be pretty quick to say this person hangs out with uncool people, or this person doesn't fit with us and here's why I don't like them, or they wore the wrong sweater. I don't think professionally run private clubs are like that, but I do think that they act on information that comes in that's subjective and interesting.
41:35 so that's not going to change whether you're using chemistry thank you so much, paul, always love learning and chatting with you. If you're interested in stepping up your member vetting, head on over to membervettingcom. Set up a consult with Paul Dank and ensure your club's safety and security. Hope you all enjoyed that episode. If you did like share, subscribe with someone who you think can use the information. As always, any and all support and sharing of the content in the channel means the absolute world and costs nothing. Until next time, catch you on the flippity flip.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Amazon Music
Castro
RSS Feed